STBY, Municipality of Amsterdam, various district teams (for example Neighborhood & Street Managers, Bicycle Program, Enforcement, Green, Play, Engineering Office), public transport organizations, business associations, community centers, residents' organizations
Energy & sustainability
Health & Care
Inclusive society
Physical living environment
The central starting point of each of the Straatlab projects is that the municipality would like to explore in consultation with residents, entrepreneurs and visitors what the wishes, expectations and preferences are with regard to sustainable mobility and joint use of public space. In terms of policy, there are usually some frameworks established, but choices can certainly still be made within these and preferences that have joint support can be played on.
The traditional method of first developing plans and then holding a consultation evening is not satisfactory and does not suffice for this. Both sides would like to engage in discussions at an earlier stage and more proactively in order to arrive at appealing solutions. Some projects are aimed at an upcoming and radical redevelopment of a certain street or neighbourhood, while other projects focus on improving busy hotspots in the city. Sometimes it is about creating more space for pedestrians in narrow streets, sometimes about finding better solutions for bicycle and car parking in busy neighbourhoods, and sometimes about creating more opportunities for greenery, playing, staying and meeting.
In this way, Amsterdam is working on a step-by-step transition to make the use of public space more humane, cleaner and safer and would like everyone to be able to participate in the consultation on this. This is not about rolling out a detailed blueprint, but about specifying precise plans within broadly defined policy frameworks. The most important dilemmas are not small trivial design issues, but strategic considerations that are part of a broader transition towards sustainable and healthy use of public space in the city. The municipality would like to receive input and consultation on this from stakeholders, instead of making unilateral, top-down decisions.

Jointly tackling complex transitions
Cities face multiple urgent societal challenges, which are interrelated in a complex transition process:
The city is quite full and the available public space is limited. Cars (driving and parking) have had priority for a long time, but that is slowly changing. More priority is needed for sustainable mobility and more greenery and also for more exercise, meeting and playing. This is a large-scale and complex transition, in which a series of choices must be made for subtle adjustments over time. Many different, but interrelated dilemmas are addressed here. The city is not a 'blank canvas' where you can simply start again with a clean design slate. And to make the changes feasible, the municipality must also work as much as possible within existing maintenance and replacement schedules.
Thinking about the change
Policymakers and civil servants want input from residents on these issues for developing new policies and initiating projects, and they are looking for stronger involvement from residents and other users of the city (such as entrepreneurs, workers and visitors). This concerns both the direction and the speed of changes. Choices can indeed be made, provided that they fit within the set policy frameworks.
The intention is to move beyond a traditional consultation evening – for which the government already has a detailed blueprint ready – and residents can actually only object. However, this is also a difficult challenge, because historically built up reflexes play a role on both sides. For example: residents can sometimes be suspicious of the government, which makes it difficult to convince them that there really is still room to think along. And policymakers and civil servants sometimes find it difficult to enter into an open discussion, because they are easily placed in the role of the 'bad guy' and are therefore mainly forced onto the defensive. It is important on both sides not to end up in such traditional us-versus-them discussions, but instead to enter into an open dialogue. The role of a neutral discussion leader is very useful here and STBY fulfils this role as part of the Straatlab approach described in this case study.
An example of a recent project is an extensive participation process in the Gerard Doubuurt (part of De Pijp in the Zuid district). The public space in this neighbourhood was due for major maintenance. The Zuid district wanted to involve local residents and entrepreneurs at an early stage. In mutual cooperation, an advisory document was drawn up with a whole series of suggestions for improving the public space in the neighbourhood. This 'Public Space Plan' can be found on the website of the district. The consultation on the improvement suggestions took place over a period of nine months and had various ups and downs. During the entire period there was a 'process advisory group' of representatives of all parties involved (residents, entrepreneurs, civil servants and policy makers) who met approximately every two months, facilitated by STBY. There was a budget for two large neighbourhood surveys and it was jointly decided which methods would be used for this. The first neighbourhood survey was an online interactive map where everyone from the neighbourhood could indicate places that needed attention and what suggestions for improvement they had. STBY then processed this into a report that was shared with the neighbourhood. The second neighbourhood survey was a series of Street Labs in which people involved from the neighbourhood could discuss priorities, preferences and considerations with each other regarding the various improvement suggestions. (Due to the pandemic, these Street Lab sessions were held online, which was a shame, but also went well.) All suggestions from the neighborhood were collected by STBY in a final report, which was then used as input by designers from the City District to draw up the final Public Space Plan.
The participation project in the Gerard Doubuurt is an example of a long-term exchange between the municipality and stakeholders from the neighbourhood. Several other Straatlab projects had a much shorter duration, often around three months. For example, the Straatlab about the crowds in the Haarlemmerstraat/-dijk, in which the municipality looked for short-term suggestions for improving traffic flows (cyclists, scooters and cars), parking (bicycles, scooters, cars and loading/unloading) and space on the sidewalk for pedestrians. For this Straatlab, a general survey was first conducted in the neighbourhood with an online survey, followed by a series of extensive group discussions with stakeholders from the neighbourhood. A detailed description of this project and the Straatlab method used can be found in the English-language book 'Seeing the City'.


Street Labs: Exploring Preferences and Generating Ideas
STBY has developed an approach for these projects that we call 'Street Labs'. In this approach, several Key Enabling Methodologies (KEMs) play a central role:
Participation & Co-creation
The main method within the Straatlab approach is a series of co-creative sessions with residents, entrepreneurs/employees and visitors of a certain neighbourhood. This has proven to be a successful way to openly engage in conversation with a random mix of people, including listeners from the municipality.
Each Streetlab session has about 30 to 40 participants, who talk to each other in small groups. Each table has a discussion leader from STBY.
The discussion at the tables is open, but well prepared and structured. People can say anything in principle, as long as it is relevant to the topic and with respect for the other participants. The discussion leader ensures that everyone has enough time to speak and that the comments made are well documented. Most tables also have one or two people from the municipality listening in, who can provide further explanation if questions arise, for example about what is or is not possible. They have no formal role to represent the municipality in the conversation and can also participate in the conversation as fellow Amsterdammers.
Each project will have multiple sessions on multiple days and times, to give as many people as possible the chance to participate and also to compare the main themes that emerge from the different sessions. If a particular idea comes up repeatedly and resonates in different sessions, then there is probably something in it.
This aspect of the Street Lab approach builds on KEM methodologies such as participatory research and participatory designA combination of qualitative in-depth research (with attention to personal needs, preferences and motivations) and collaborative idea generation (where people discuss with each other how to combine their different ideas).
For several projects, we have used other methods besides group discussions, such as surveys, intercept interviews, observations and desk research. This was done to combine multiple forms of input from the neighbourhood and also to broaden the reach.

Vision & Imagination
The role of the STBY team in these projects is not only that of researchers, but also of designers. We use our creativity in preparing materials to stimulate, focus and document the discussion during the Street Labs. In the report phase, after a thorough analysis of the collected data, we also use our creative abilities to create 'inspiration images' that visually indicate which suggestions/ideas/visions emerged in the Street Labs and have been elaborated in an appealing way. We do not take the place of the final designers at the municipal engineering firm. We mainly indicate 'solution directions' that we know have support within the community.
This aspect of the Streetlab approach builds on the KEM methodologies such as storytelling and visualizations. Recurring themes and signals from the feedback of the participants in the Street Labs are expressed in appealing short stories and images - often by using photos, quotes and illustrations. It is important to stay as close as possible to the original data and to bring it together well in a summary that can be clearly communicated. This concerns future changes, so some imagination is needed to clearly convey the core of the idea. At the same time, we do not want to give the impression that these are final designs, so the sketches are deliberately kept quite rough.

System change
Street labs contribute as a means to system change at two levels:
By regularly engaging in open discussions with all stakeholders (approach), the chance of a positive system transition (outcome) is greater.
This aspect of the Street Lab approach builds on methodologies such as Pragmatic Reflexivity and Dialogic Design. The focus here is on contributing to transitions through an open, joint process of exploring an issue and generating action-oriented ideas for solutions. This is primarily about joint experimentation and learning, with sensitivity to underlying tensions and power structures and a joint effort to get past these through open dialogue.

Mix of short and long term changes
The results of each project are a mix of directly implementable local adjustments and improvements for the wider city that can be further developed and realised in the longer term. Some improvements are relatively easy and quick to realise because they fall within the mandate and budget of a specific department. Especially the somewhat smaller local improvements in specific streets and neighbourhoods are often implemented in the short term after the completion of a Street Lab project, which is a very pleasant direct result for all those involved. Many of the other, larger desired solutions intervene at the system level of the city and often cannot be initiated on the basis of a single project (such as the construction of large underground bicycle parking garages, or the gradual reduction of the number of car parking spaces in the neighbourhoods). Implementing these improvements requires, among other things, cooperation between different departments and this usually takes more time. The results of the successive Street Labs clearly showed the increasing momentum for these major changes, which also increased confidence in the municipality about their implementation and some of these changes have now been initiated.
Several outcomes of the Street Labs were a positive surprise, as they turned out to have more support than many had expected:
Some signals in the results of the Street Labs are still too speculative and controversial at this point to be developed into concrete suggestions for improvement. These signals point in the direction of still open question marks that should be explored further in the future:
