CASE

The Empathy Journey

Co-founder of (digital) design studio Fabrique and former professor of concept design (2015-2021) Jeroen van Erp was at the heart of the VR project 'Alsof ik je al ken…' – to create social cohesion in the Eindhoven district of Meerhoven. And it worked. 'The research results confirm that stepping into each other's world through VR leads to more empathy for the other.'

KEMs

INVOLVED

Factory
LB MGMT
Delft University of Technology
Municipality of Eindhoven
The Effenaar
VR Gorilla
Sparkle
Fontys Universities of Applied Sciences
Sponsored by ASML and CLICKNL

THEME

Safety
Inclusive society

Can you design for empathy? Yes!

Based on the idea that the creative industry can make useful contributions to solving social problems, such as reducing dormant conflicts and polarization at all levels (think corona, nitrogen, Ter Apel, the cancel culture, etc.), Jeroen van Erp and Liesbeth Bonekamp initiated the VR film 'Alsof ik je al ken…'.

The project focuses on tensions between young people and residents of a shopping centre in the Meerhoven district of Eindhoven, and was created by the Bubble Games consortium, consisting of Fabrique, LB MGMT, TU Delft, the Municipality of Eindhoven, Fontys Hogescholen, the Effenaar, VR Gorilla and Fonkeling. With the aim of understanding each other better, reducing tensions and making new agreements that both groups can agree on.

Simply put, the groups literally stepped into each other's world during the experiment. And it works. Van Erp: 'On the one hand, the technology creates distance - everyone can calmly tell their story. On the other hand, they get a glimpse into each other's 'normal' lives, which creates empathy and shared suffering.'

To add: 'There is a lot of knowledge in the field of polarization and social cohesion, but as designers we have done little with it so far.'

'The societal challenges we face all involve major transformations and behavioral changes, and social cohesion is essential in this regard'

The social challenge

Relieve tensions

“The greatest risk to humanity is not so much the danger of wars, climate change and pandemics, but our unwillingness to work together on solutions.” ~Ian Goldin, Oxford University

Van Erp: 'With this quote in mind, there is an urgency to develop knowledge and cases on how to create that willingness, on how to reduce tensions between groups. Two questions are important for this: how design your empathy and how can you apply that in journeys to change people's attitudes towards others/each other?

The social problem (and therefore the challenge) is the disappearance of social cohesion due to the rapidly changing world. It goes without saying that polarization is a complex matter to which we hardly have an answer. Polarization undermines social cohesion, while that is considered an essential part of the humus layer of our society.

Polarization is a problem at several levels: at the political level, between rival tribes, but also in the case of neighborhood disputes and problems in deprived neighborhoods.

The Meerhoven district was nominated as a case by the municipality because they had heard from their area coordinator that there were tensions, but not yet a conflict that had gotten out of hand. With the consortium we wanted to contribute to solving the polarization via a design intervention using VR technology.

With the underlying idea that the major social challenges we face are all about extensive transformations and much-needed behavioral changes. And that good social cohesion is essential in this and accelerates those processes.' 

The KEMs

The Empathy Journey – From Negative to Positive

Van Erp continues: 'The goal was to find an answer to the question of whether you can design for empathy and thus develop practical tools to counteract polarization. Based on theory and models, we developed a hypothetical journey on how to bring opposing groups closer together.

The project was approached as a social design through research project. The knowledge base for the project is formed by the conflict model of Brandsma, the framework for empathy design of Ko van Batson and the empathy journey of Kouprie and Sleeswijk Visser. Furthermore, practical examples were looked at where VR was applied. For example, Hack the Planet once did a great project to bring rival tribes together in Uganda. These examples were not approached from a theory and an intended journey, nor from 'a bigger plan'. We did that.

In addition, the journey design includes participation & co-creation and behavior & empowerment models are used to bring parties together and influence their actions. The intervention is intended to help them understand each other better, making it easier to work together on a solution, which is then also jointly elaborated.

We first tested the hypothetical journey, which showed that what we had come up with was correct. Some people who have seen the VR film wonder if 'that VR' (as experimental environment) is needed now. What has been shown in the research is that a 7-minute video in VR, in which you step into the other person's world, can tilt your view from negative to positive. That is quite something.

But it's not just the VR, it's also a matter of knowing which questions to ask the participants in the video, so that they can give answers that meet the interests of the other. That's how you design empathy.'

'The idea was and is that the knowledge and experience gained from the project can also be applied in other neighborhoods, within companies or perhaps within a government coalition'

The result

Convincingly immersed

Van Erp finally: 'The idea was and is that the knowledge and experience gained from the project can also be applied in other neighborhoods, within companies or perhaps within a government coalition. That looks promising.

The direct result can be seen in the 24-minute VR film As if I already knew you… (in English: As if I already knew you…). The participants in the experiment have come closer together through the VR experience and have therefore been able to work together on a solution in the neighborhood. This has been presented to the municipality of Eindhoven and a follow-up plan is now being made together with the young and older residents.

In addition, as mentioned, there are research results that confirm that stepping into each other's world through VR leads to more empathy for the other; with the right guidance, you are convincingly immersed in the world of another, which does something to you.

Of course, it's a hassle, with a 360-degree camera and those glasses. And VR technology is extremely impactful, but also laborious and expensive. What we're striving for is that we gain a better understanding of what it does exactly and how it works in your brain so that we can use this knowledge to create something simpler - a pocket version of the immersive journey – can think of. That should be possible: think of how people can lose themselves in a phone screen. We are currently investigating this with Fontys Hogescholen. We are actually going from start-up to scale-up, ha!'

Looking back: 'Well, how such an idea/method comes about... It is something that accumulates in your head over the years, where you think: 'Would it also be possible to design emotion or empathy directly, in addition to all the tangible and now digital? When we had the partners in place, the biggest obstacle was recruiting participants, which we underestimated. Because the municipality was a partner in the project, it was distrusted by the neighborhood.

We have had participants who withdrew because they were persuaded by neighbours who were more radicalised in the conflict. You could start over again. And so on, but apparently we have succeeded in creating social cohesion within the project in the end.' Laughs: 'As a designer and researcher, you have to set a good example first.'

Written by: Nils Adriaans